With her always handy camera, Avery captures all the hottest happenings in Portland.
July 22, 2009
555 cook revamps Fit to Eat
Roughly three years ago Mike Mastronardi used to manage the sandwich shop and salad bar Fit to Eat. But after a year there he left to further his culinary knowledge, working at two foodie hotspots: The Harraseeket Inn in Freeport and Five Fifty-Five in Portland.
"Five Fifty-Five really taught me how to cook," Mike says of the fine dining restaurant, where he still works Sunday brunch.
Recently he was offered the opportunity to take over the reins at Fit to Eat, and he jumped at it. He re-opened the shop two weeks ago with a pared down menu and scratch made breads.
Everything is made fresh to order, with sandwiches that include the Old Port ($6.99), with roast beef, avocado, romaine, tomato, cheddar and cucumber wasbi mayo, the California ($7.50), with salmon, avocado, carrots, cucumbers, romaine and cucumber wasbi mayo, and the Santa Fe ($6.99), with chicken, romaine, red peppers, banana peppers, salsa and cheddar.
There's one vegetarian sandwich on the menu, the Portobello ($6.75), with arugula, roasted red peppers, cheddar and horseradish mayo, and there's also a daily vegetarian special.
Each day Mike makes the Tuscan and focaccia rolls, plus English muffins.
Here's Mike whipping up one of his signature scrambled egg sandwiches served until 11 am on the English muffins. Choices include bacon ($5), sausage ($5) and veggie ($6).
He's making all the sauces and dressings from scratch and is sourcing his supplies from Native Maine, Micucci Wholesale and the Fresh Approach market in the West End.
"I don't believe in canned or frozen," Mike says. "I hope that's what sets us apart."
He offers one soup a day, and each is cream-based. Today's soup is carrot cardamon ($2.50/$3.50). He's working on a chilled cucumber creme fraiche soup and a tomato bisque will follow.
In the future, he hopes to add bagels, gluten-free bread and possibly pizza (but that's farther down the road).
"I hope people will be able to tell the difference between homemade mayonnaise and dressing and the bottled stuff," he says.
Fit to Eat is located above The Big Easy and next to Sebago at 65 Market St. It is open Mon-Fri from 7 am-5 pm. Once O'Natural's closes up shop, Fit to Eat may add hours on Saturday. To place an order to go, call 761-4441.
Comments
How is making things from scratch not healthy, even at o,naturals if you asked what was in a dressing they would have to go look at a label. In my opinion if some one can name the ingredients off of the top of their head, then that to me is healthy. You know it is fresh and there isnt all those preservatives in it. I say good luck to fit to eat. I will check it ou soon
Posted by jimJuly 27, 2009 09:27 PM
The fact that Fit to Eat is using real fresh ingredients and is buying local produce it will surely be a great new business for the downtown Portland area. Sounds to me like it's healthy for the body and the community. Let's go out and support this new local business that does certainly seem to provide food that is 'Fit to Eat'. Let's leave the negative comments out.
Posted by JCJuly 28, 2009 02:33 PM
looks like your well on your way cuz i know the time left in a day once in this business is little to none so when and if you get the tome drop me a guick E,note
Posted by richard vazzanoJuly 30, 2009 10:05 AM
How refreshing to find homemade breads and the freshest ingredients in town. I treated my family who were visiting from out of town to lunch and they raved all night long about their meal. I will be back and look forward to bringing other friends when they come into town!! Thanks Fit to Eat!!
Posted by GiaAugust 2, 2009 09:01 PM
I randomly met Mike on the patio at Nova Res the other night. Heck of a nice guy. He told me all about Fit to Eat. Fresh, local ingredients. Solid pitch. I can't way to try it out.
Posted by Brock ForemanAugust 20, 2009 10:31 AM
Mike is very vocal out his focus on fresh, delicious and consistent food. From what I have seen so far his gourmet training serves him well and I always feel welcome when walking in the door. Plus he has reasonably priced sandwiches on daily baked homemade rolls! what could be better?
Posted by joshua fAugust 22, 2009 08:52 PM
Post a comment
Latest Comments
joshua f commented: Mike is very vocal out his focus on fresh, delicious and consistent food. F...
Last Supper commented: The restaurant should have been named "Disgrace"! Seats about 130...maybe ...
Sara Deane commented: Standard baking does not make or sell K's Vegan Delights nor does she use o...
leer 127 commented: this is dope really dont get in to portland to much but this is sick. from ...
Kristy commented: I'm never going back. Terrible service followed by bland, overpriced food....
Michelle commented: Thanks for the article, Avery! I linked it on Goodwill's FB page!...


I thought the whole point of Fit To Eat was that it was supposed to be healthy? With O'Naturals closing, there's a niche that needs filling. Thanks for checking it out - now I know not to go there.
Posted by TammyJuly 24, 2009 11:31 AM