Search Maine Yellow Pages 
Log In | Register | Help

Because I Said So
Amy Beth Brochu-Krikken is a mom of three boys 3 and under, is learning to survive the craziness that is motherhood, and she is doing it with a sense of humor, well mostly!

Blog Index
May 18, 2007
To spank or not to spank: I know the answer

Monday night was the first time in my parenting career that I lost control. Correction: I didn't lose control, cause I don't think I had it to begin with. I was out of control, and there were two little boys in charge.

This lasted a good half an hour. It was time for them to be in their beds.
They did not listen, they climbed over the gate, they laughed in my face, they were not taking me seriously at all. I tried yelling, that did not work. Then I reached the end of my rope. I spanked.

I have pat them on their bottoms before, but this was more than that, this was more of a real spanking. Not the old fashioned kind, no belts, no formal ceremony out of it. Just a firm spank on the butt.

And I felt terrible. I have come to believe that spanking does not work as they were right back at the same behavior after they stopped crying. I did not like some of the advice I received upon telling this story, ie: spank them again, only do it harder.

So it was time to consult with the big wigs, the authors on such lovely topics as "How to live happily ever after with three boys 3 and under". "The smart parents' guide on how to prevent years of therapy for your children." And my favorite book of all, "How to prevent yourself from putting your head in the oven, and other tricks of the parenting trade." Oh wait, those are the future titles of my books, I just have to wait a bit longer to publish them, until I'm out of the parenting woods, if you will.

Now don't go thinking that I am a crazy liberal who doesn't believe in disciplining. In fact, I am very much of the belief that it must be done. It is how the real world works, one's actions have a consequence.

But I absolutely do not subscribe to this "spare the rod spoil the child" idea. I guess I have a bone to pick with the author of that book. ACTUALLY I HAVE MORE THAN ONE BONE TO PICK, BUT HONEY, THAT'S A WHOLE OTHER BLOG.

Now I do not propose to have all of the answers, but I will not choose the easy path. PS- I also wish to spare myself the horrible feelings that go along with spanking. That does not mean that I won't pat their bottom when they are too young to understand that something is hot for instance.

But as far as spanking goes, it just makes no sense, I'm going to spank in order to show my little boy that it is not ok to hit his brother? That's just idiotic.
It's a much less servere version of hey, let's fry that guy in the electric chair for the murder that he committed.

I don't want the blood on my hands thank you very much. And in the case of spanking, I don't want the guilt and shame on my hands from knowing that I have done wrong. Now that just might be where the big book and I agree.

Posted by Amy Krikken at 02:34 PM

E-mail this entry to a friend

Comments

spank away

Posted by macsgirl
May 18, 2007 05:24 PM

Amy,
I was a firm believer in spanking pre-child. Now I'm not so sure. I also believe that discipline is very important and I think there are other ways to do it. Although I have spanked before, and sometimes I felt that it wasn't the right thing to do after I had done it.
I have heard two interpretations of that scripture you quoted. One is the interpretation you were referring to--spanking--the rod being a stick or staff. But in Biblical times, shepherding apparently was an important part of their lives.
We all have heard Psalm 23 about "The Lord is my Shepherd". The Bible has a lot of analogies to sheep and shepherding. Well,anyway, I digress...it was something the original audience understood and I guess the rod was also used in shepherding as a guide for sheep, to steer them in one direction or another or as a gentle prod with a shepherd's crook. I like that interpretation better. I'm sure some angry shepherds used their rod more firmly or angrily than others, who knows? The rod doesn't mean something has to physically hurt. Discipline can be much more creative than that for those of us uncomfortable with spanking!

Posted by Libby
May 19, 2007 09:41 PM

Well I, for one, am glad that my father chose to spank me when I went past the boundary he had set for my bike-riding safety in our driveway. I would much rather 'suffer' a sore bottom for a few minutes than become road-kill. I feel horrible, too, when I have to spank my child (which is quite rare) - it's not SUPPOSED to feel good. When done in love and in the best interests of the child's safety and discipline (not in anger or retribution) a spanking is very effective and might be the only way to get through to an unruly, rebellious child - even if it's just a temporary rebellion. And let's keep punishment in perspective: you go get caught going 10 over the speed limit, you pay a fine; you blow through a stop sign at 90 mph and you go to jail; you run over your ex and their new family in a fit of rage and you should be pushin' up daisies yourself. The consequences should fit the crime. Let's stop making a victim of everyone by blaming their circumstances/upbringing... except for those kids who never got spanked - they don't understand/appreciate authority or boundaries so they should be given a second, third, fourth, etc. chance when they break the law.

Posted by Matt S.
May 22, 2007 08:40 AM

Post a comment









Remember personal info?







Please enter the code as seen in the image above:



Blog Index
Updates
Sign up to be notified when there's a new entry
RSS
Subscribe
Archives
By category